US proposes ending H-1B 'deference' rule, putting visa extensions under full review

The US Department of Homeland Security has proposed ending the rule that tells immigration officers to give "deference" to earlier approvals when a foreign worker's visa extension comes up for decision. The proposal, titled "Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility", was published in the Federal Register on Wednesday, 14 October 2026. It would remove the provision at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), under which US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) generally accepts a previous approval involving the same employer, worker and facts. Comments are open until 13 November 2026. The change affects extension petitions for H-1B, L-1 and other work visas filed on Form I-129, categories that include very large numbers of Indian technology professionals.

For a worker already in the US on an H-1B visa, the most stressful moment is often not the first approval but the extension. Under the deference rule, if nothing material has changed in the job, the employer or the worker's eligibility, an officer reviewing the extension generally relies on the earlier decision instead of re-examining the whole case. Removing that protection means every extension could be judged afresh, as if it were a new petition.

Immigration lawyers expect that to lead to more requests for evidence, longer processing times and a higher chance of refusal, even for people whose circumstances have not changed. The law firm Fragomen described the move as the administration again proposing to eliminate deference, a reference to the 2017 decision that rescinded the earlier policy. Employers would have to prepare extension files as carefully as first-time petitions.

For India the stakes are large. Indian-born professionals account for a large share of H-1B approvals, as the USCIS figures above show, and many of them work for US technology companies and Indian IT services firms with American operations. A tougher extension process adds uncertainty to careers, home purchases and children's schooling for families who have often lived in the US for years. It also comes on top of the new fee on fresh H-1B petitions and the recent end of automatic extensions of work permits for many H-4 spouses.

Short-term: Nothing changes for pending or approved cases yet. The proposal is open for public comment until 13 November, and the existing rule applies until a final rule is published. Lawyers say the proposal would not reopen past approvals.

Long-term: If adopted, each H-1B or L-1 extension would face full review. Employers may file earlier and with more documents, and some may lean further on hiring in India or other countries rather than moving staff to the US.

Who is affected: Indian engineers and IT professionals on H-1B and L-1 visas in the US, their families, the US and Indian companies that employ them, and students in India planning a career that includes a US work visa.

Questions and Answers