Family Values

CARA NOC case: Delhi High Court to hear adopted girl's Australia move

By Priya NairStaff Writer, Peepals Shakti
WhatsAppX
Representative image: family holding child hands

Representative image: Nanas_World / Pixabay

The Delhi High Court ruled on 19 November that it can hear an Australia-based couple's plea against CARA over their adopted daughter's NOC; hearing on 2 December.

CARA NOC: what happened

The Delhi High Court ruled on Thursday, 19 November 2026, that it can hear a petition by an adoptive couple, now Australian citizens, who want a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) so their adopted daughter can join them in Australia. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma rejected the government's objection that the case belonged to a court elsewhere because the adoption and the passport application had taken place in Amritsar, Punjab. The petition will now be heard on its merits on Wednesday, 2 December.

CARA NOC: key facts

  • The objection to the Delhi court hearing the case was raised by the Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar.
  • The court held that CARA, the main body the couple seeks relief against, is located in New Delhi and took its decision there, so part of the cause of action arose in Delhi.
  • The adoption deed was registered in Amritsar and was recognised by a civil court in January 2024; the court treated these documents as background, since they were not under challenge.
  • The couple told the court that when they applied for the child's passport in January 2022, the passport authorities would not proceed without a CARA NOC.
  • The court noted that the child's relocation had been pending for nearly five years and said sending the couple to another forum would not serve justice or the child's best interests.
  • CARA has opposed the petition on its merits, arguing that it is legally barred from issuing the NOC without the required approvals from the receiving country. It did not object to the Delhi court's jurisdiction.

CARA NOC: why it matters

For families who adopt a child in India and later settle abroad, the hardest step is often not the adoption itself but the paperwork that lets the child travel. CARA is India's central adoption authority, and its NOC was the step the passport office insisted on here. When a child adopted in India is to be taken to live in another country, the passport office and CARA each have a role, and a refusal at either stage can leave a family split between two countries for years.

This ruling does not decide whether the couple should get the NOC. It decides a narrower but practical question: where such a family can go to court. The government argued that because the adoption deed, the civil court decree and the passport application were all in Amritsar, the case should be heard by a court with jurisdiction over Punjab. Justice Sharma disagreed. The relief the couple seeks is mainly against CARA, and CARA sits and decides in New Delhi, so the Delhi High Court can hear the case. Part of the "cause of action", the facts behind the claim, arose in Delhi.

The court also weighed "forum conveniens", the idea that a case should be heard where it is most convenient and just. With the child's move already pending for close to five years, the judge said that sending the family to start again in another court would neither advance justice nor serve the child's best interests.

The merits remain open: CARA says it needs Australia's approvals first, while the couple says the child is legally theirs. An earlier order of the same High Court, by Justice Sachin Datta, had directed CARA to issue an NOC to a different Australia-based couple holding Overseas Citizen of India status in a similar adoption, though each case turns on its own facts.

Peepals timeline: In January 2022 the couple applied for the child's passport and were told a CARA NOC was needed. In January 2024 a civil court recognised the adoption deed registered in Amritsar. On 19 November 2026 the Delhi High Court rejected the government's objection to its jurisdiction and kept the case. On 2 December 2026 the petition is listed for hearing on its merits, nearly five years after the passport application.

CARA NOC: impact

Short-term: The couple's petition stays in the Delhi High Court, and CARA, the Ministry of External Affairs and the passport office will have to answer it on its merits rather than on where it was filed.

Long-term: The reasoning gives other adoptive families a clear point: when the main grievance is a decision CARA took in New Delhi, the Delhi High Court can hear the challenge even if the adoption and passport steps happened in another state.

Who is affected: Families living abroad who adopt a child in India; adopted children waiting to join their parents; CARA and regional passport offices; and family lawyers handling inter-country adoption.

What to watch next: The hearing on 2 December 2026, where the court will take up whether CARA can be directed to issue the NOC without the receiving country's approvals.

CARA NOC: key takeaway

Adoptive parents abroad stuck on a CARA decision can now look to the Delhi High Court, and the 2 December hearing will show how far it will go on the merits.

CARA NOC: questions and answers

What is a CARA NOC and why does it matter for an adopted child?

It is a No Objection Certificate from the Central Adoption Resource Authority, India's central adoption authority. In this case the passport authorities refused to process the adopted child's passport without it, so the child could not travel to join the parents in Australia.

Did the Delhi High Court order CARA to issue the NOC?

No. On 19 November 2026 the court only decided that it has jurisdiction to hear the petition. Whether CARA must issue the NOC will be argued from 2 December 2026.

Why did the government say the case should not be heard in Delhi?

The Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar, argued that the adoption deed, the civil court decree and the passport application were all in Amritsar, so a court there was the right forum.

Disclaimer: Prepared by the Peepals newsroom from publicly available sources with AI assistance. Information is accurate to the best of our knowledge at the time of publication and may change. Images may be representative. Not professional advice. Report an error via our contact page.

#CARA NOC#Delhi High Court adoption#inter-country adoption#adopted child passport#Central Adoption Resource Authority

By Priya Nair, Staff WriterCovers Leadership & Growth and more for Peepals Shakti. All stories by Priya Nair

Your week ahead, every Sunday. Free.

Exam and result dates, IPOs opening, scheme deadlines, government holidays and the RBI decision for the next 7 days, plus the week's top stories. One email a week, unsubscribe in one click.

Priya Nair is a pen name of the Peepals Global Editorial Team, which researches, fact-checks and publishes every story. The portrait is an illustration.

Responsible for this story: the Peepals Global Editorial Team, led by editor Prashant Sonar. How we report

More from Peepals Shakti

Your week ahead, every Sunday. Free.

Exam and result dates, IPOs opening, scheme deadlines, government holidays and the RBI decision for the next 7 days, plus the week's top stories. One email a week, unsubscribe in one click.